Digging sustainability: scaling and sectoring of sovereignty in Greenland and Nunavut mining discourses
Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding › Book chapter › Research › peer-review
Standard
Digging sustainability: scaling and sectoring of sovereignty in Greenland and Nunavut mining discourses. / Jacobsen, Marc.
The Politics of Sustainability in the Arctic: Reconfiguring Identity, Space, and Time. ed. / Ulrik Pram Gad; Jeppe Strandsbjerg. Routledge, 2019. p. 52-73 (Routledge Studies in Sustainability).Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding › Book chapter › Research › peer-review
Harvard
APA
Vancouver
Author
Bibtex
}
RIS
TY - CHAP
T1 - Digging sustainability: scaling and sectoring of sovereignty in Greenland and Nunavut mining discourses
AU - Jacobsen, Marc
PY - 2019
Y1 - 2019
N2 - ‘Sustainability’ is often articulated in the Greenland and Nunavut mining discourses where the exploitation of mineral resources is perceived as a key component in their respective continuous nation-building processes. The concept is, to some degree, contested by Indigenous definitions, but the Brundtland Report’s 1987 description of sustainable development is generally the main point of reference, hence reproducing the hegemonic perception. By digging deeper into key mining documents and public hearings regarding the proposed Citronen Fiord zinc mine and the Mary River iron mine, this chapter shows how the referent object is placed on different scales and sectors within the two discourses. Whereas the national economy is given precedence in Greenland in the paramount aim for independence, the local social sustainability gets more attention in the Nunavut mining discourse, which further allows more room for disagreement. This reflects the different directions of their respective postcolonial developments, where Greenland is described as a ‘country’ on the way to ‘independence’, while Nunavut is a ‘territory’ with the declared goal of ‘devolution’. Denmark and Canada are largely left out of the respective communication, but in the few instances they are mentioned it is clear how sovereignty is central to the question of who gets to decide what to sustain. While Nunavut loyally respects Canada’s sovereignty and explicitly states that the mining projects sustain Canadian sovereignty in the North, Danish interference in the Citronen Fiord project triggers postcolonial concerns in Greenland.
AB - ‘Sustainability’ is often articulated in the Greenland and Nunavut mining discourses where the exploitation of mineral resources is perceived as a key component in their respective continuous nation-building processes. The concept is, to some degree, contested by Indigenous definitions, but the Brundtland Report’s 1987 description of sustainable development is generally the main point of reference, hence reproducing the hegemonic perception. By digging deeper into key mining documents and public hearings regarding the proposed Citronen Fiord zinc mine and the Mary River iron mine, this chapter shows how the referent object is placed on different scales and sectors within the two discourses. Whereas the national economy is given precedence in Greenland in the paramount aim for independence, the local social sustainability gets more attention in the Nunavut mining discourse, which further allows more room for disagreement. This reflects the different directions of their respective postcolonial developments, where Greenland is described as a ‘country’ on the way to ‘independence’, while Nunavut is a ‘territory’ with the declared goal of ‘devolution’. Denmark and Canada are largely left out of the respective communication, but in the few instances they are mentioned it is clear how sovereignty is central to the question of who gets to decide what to sustain. While Nunavut loyally respects Canada’s sovereignty and explicitly states that the mining projects sustain Canadian sovereignty in the North, Danish interference in the Citronen Fiord project triggers postcolonial concerns in Greenland.
KW - Faculty of Social Sciences
KW - Arctic
KW - Greenland
KW - Nunavut
KW - Mining
KW - sustainable development
KW - Sustainability
KW - Discourse analysis
KW - Geopolitics
KW - Postcolonialism
UR - https://www.routledge.com/The-Politics-of-Sustainability-in-the-Arctic-Reconfiguring-Identity-Space/Gad-Strandsbjerg/p/book/9781138491830
M3 - Book chapter
SN - 9781138491830
T3 - Routledge Studies in Sustainability
SP - 52
EP - 73
BT - The Politics of Sustainability in the Arctic
A2 - Gad, Ulrik Pram
A2 - Strandsbjerg, Jeppe
PB - Routledge
ER -
ID: 189313801